[Techtalk] Firewall blocks download -- why?

Brenda Bell k15a-list-linuxchix at theotherbell.com
Sat Mar 29 14:03:42 EST 2003


I'm been staring at this for an hour and can't figure out what's wrong.

I'm using wget to download a file.  The URL is
ftp://download2.eclipse.org/R-2.1-200303272130/eclipse-SDK-2.1-win32.zip. 
wget connects to 204.138.98.19 port 21 OK, but then I get a message that says:

204.138.98.19:37146: No route to host

On my NetBSD firewall, I get the following in my log:

ipmon[88]: 12:34:32.086127 tlp1 @0:35 b download2.eclipse.org,ftp ->
111-195-35-64.dialup.mcttelecom.com,53692 PR tcp len 20 27136 -AFP IN

If I'm interpreting this correctly, some response from
download2.eclipse.org is definitely being blocked.  ipfstat -hin indicates
that the blocking rule is my catchall at the end of ipf.conf:

@35 block in log quick from any to any

However, I have "earlier" rules in ipf.conf that should allow me to start
an ftp transfer from inside my network and accept all the responses:

@3 pass out quick on tlp1 proto tcp from any to any keep state keep frags
@4 pass out quick on tlp1 proto udp from any to any keep state keep frags
@5 pass out quick on tlp1 proto icmp from any to any keep state keep frags

When I try to ping download2.eclipse.org, I get the following output:

PING download2.eclipse.org (204.138.98.19) from 192.168.2.66 : 56(84) bytes
of data.
>From Z-hssi4-1-1.gw3.mtl1.sprint-canada.net (209.5.111.74): Packet filtered

Can anyone give me a clue as to what I'm missing here?

-- 
Brenda
http://opensource.theotherbell.com



More information about the Techtalk mailing list